Key takeaways
- Entry prices are far apart: Otterly.AI from $29/mo, Peec AI from $95/mo, Gauge from $599/mo. Gauge is not really a lightweight tracker.
- All three cap self-serve engine choice at three. Peec and Otterly let you pick which three. Gauge fixes them as ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Copilot.
- Peec AI has unlimited users and the cheapest analytics per dollar. Otterly wins on sticker price. Gauge is the only one of the three that bundles content (18 articles a month).
- Some roundups are stale. Otterly's current page says 3 of 7 engines, not four, and Peec does list gap analysis on every plan.
- If you want tracking plus execution at a small-team price, look at a platform that also writes and publishes, such as Promptwatch.
Why this comparison needs a caveat
The title says lightweight, but one of these three tools is not. Gauge starts at $599 a month. Peec AI starts at $95 and Otterly.AI at $29. Putting them side by side is useful because small teams do shop across that range, usually after reading a roundup that treats them as interchangeable.
They are not. Before getting into plans, here is the one question that sorts them: is your bottleneck data or time? If you have someone who will read dashboards and act, a cheap tracker is fine. If nobody has the hours, paying for something that produces content starts to make sense.
A word on sources. Several third-party comparisons I read are vendor-written or out of date. The Gauge-authored Peec comparison says Peec has no gap analysis, but Peec's own pricing page lists gap analysis on every plan. A get3rd roundup says Otterly includes four engines for $29, but Otterly's current page says 3 of 7. I used the vendor pricing pages for everything below, and the per-prompt figures are my own arithmetic.
The three tools at a glance

| Gauge | Peec AI | Otterly.AI | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | $599/mo (Growth) | $95/mo (Starter) | $29/mo (Lite) |
| Prompts at entry tier | 600 | 50 | 20 |
| Engines at entry tier | ChatGPT, AI Mode, Copilot (fixed) | Any 3 of 8 | Any 3 of 7 |
| Users | 3 seats | Unlimited | No limit found |
| Content generation | 18 articles/mo, CMS publishing | Recommendations, no article generation seen | Recommendations, no article generation seen |
| Tracking frequency | Daily | Daily | Daily |
| Best for | Teams that want tracking plus content | Analytics-minded small teams | Smallest budgets, first-time testers |
Pricing, tier by tier
Gauge
Growth is $599 a month. You get 600 prompts run daily (about 54,000 answers a month), three platforms, 18 publish-ready articles, three seats, and email and Slack support. Domains and competitors are unlimited, but you get a single location. Integrations include GA4, Search Console, Slack and MCP, with CMS publishing to Webflow, Framer, Sanity and GitHub.
Enterprise is custom and adds Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Perplexity, plus sentiment analysis and exports. Claude and Grok are optional on any plan if you bring your own API key and pay the provider directly.
Two things to flag. Sentiment analysis and exports are Enterprise-only, which is a strange gap for a $599 plan. And there is no cheap self-serve tier at all. One customer quote on Gauge's own pricing page calls it "the most expensive tool we have." Gauge claims about a penny per answer, which is a vendor claim, though the arithmetic is plausible given the volume.
Peec AI
Every plan has unlimited users, unlimited competitors, unlimited languages and daily tracking.
- Starter, $95/mo: 50 prompts, 3 models, 1 project, 1 country, 4,500 answers a month.
- Pro, $245/mo: 150 prompts, 3 models, 2 projects, 3 countries, 13,500 answers.
- Advanced, $495/mo: 350 prompts, 3 models, 5 projects, 3 countries, 31,500 answers, plus a Looker Studio integration.
- Enterprise: custom, annual, with API access, SSO, up to 26 LLMs and SOC 2 Type II on request.
Self-serve models you can choose from include ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini, Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE and Bing AI Mode. Claude and Grok are not self-serve. Gap analysis, recommended actions, citation analytics, fan-out overview, an ads library, AI Shopping with SKU-level tracking and a crawlability audit are on every plan. The objections report starts on Pro.
Otterly.AI
Pricing is credit-based, and annual billing saves 15%.
- Lite, $29/mo: 20 prompts (2,000 credits), 3 of 7 engines, 1 workspace, 3 recommendations a week.
- Standard, $189/mo: 160 prompts (15,000 credits), unlimited workspaces and recommendations, API and MCP access, a Data Studio connector. Extra credits are $65 per 5,000.
- Premium, $489/mo: 535 prompts (50,000 credits), 5,000 API and MCP requests, 1M agent analytics events, personal onboarding.
- Enterprise: custom, from 1,000 prompts, unlimited engines, SSO.
Supported engines are ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot, AI Mode, Gemini and Claude, with more listed as coming. One inconsistency: the page's meta description still shows older prompt counts (15, 100, 400), while the on-page figures say 20, 160 and 535. I used the on-page numbers. API, MCP and the Data Studio connector are not on Lite.

Cost per prompt
Raw sticker price misleads in both directions. Here is the cost per tracked prompt at each tier, calculated from the published prices.
| Plan | Monthly price | Prompts | Approx. cost per prompt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Otterly Lite | $29 | 20 | $1.45 |
| Otterly Standard | $189 | 160 | $1.18 |
| Peec Starter | $95 | 50 | $1.90 |
| Peec Pro | $245 | 150 | $1.63 |
| Peec Advanced | $495 | 350 | $1.41 |
| Gauge Growth | $599 | 600 | $1.00 |
Gauge looks cheapest per prompt, but you have to commit $599 to get there, and that price includes content production. Otterly Standard beats every Peec tier on this metric. Peec Starter is the priciest per prompt, though it also gives you unlimited seats and a feature set that does not thin out at the bottom.
Engine coverage is the quiet constraint
All three limit you to three engines on self-serve plans, so the question is which three. Peec and Otterly let you choose. Gauge does not.
That choice matters because the engines behave differently. Promptwatch Data's average sources per response report shows ChatGPT citing about 5 sources per answer, Google AI Overviews about 10, and Perplexity almost exactly 10 every day. Microsoft Copilot swung from under 2 to nearly 17 sources per response over a few weeks before settling at the low end. Gauge's fixed trio includes Copilot, so if you pick Gauge, judge that engine on monthly trends, not weekly wobbles.
For a small team, a sensible three is ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity or Gemini, depending on where your buyers go. Gauge's fixed set covers ChatGPT and AI Mode but leaves out Perplexity and AI Overviews unless you move to Enterprise.
Tool by tool: who each one suits
Gauge: pay more, get content
Gauge is the only one of the three that ships articles and publishes to your CMS. If you were going to hire a freelancer to write GEO content anyway, 18 articles a month at $599 is a real offset. Its weakness is the lack of any on-ramp. You cannot trial it cheaply, you get three seats, and sentiment is locked behind Enterprise.
Choose it if you have budget and want one login for tracking and content. Skip it if you are still working out whether AI visibility matters to your business.
Peec AI: the analyst's tracker
Peec is the best fit when several people need to look at the data. Unlimited users is rare at this price. Gap analysis, shopping tracking, an ads library and a crawlability audit on every plan make Starter richer than its prompt count suggests. The catch is that 50 prompts is thin, and Peec stops at recommendations rather than writing anything. Someone on your team needs to act on what it finds.
Otterly.AI: cheapest way to start
Otterly Lite at $29 is the low-risk way to see whether your brand shows up at all. Twenty prompts is enough for a brand check and a handful of competitor comparisons, not a program. Where it gets interesting is Standard at $189, which unlocks API, MCP and a Data Studio connector and has the best per-prompt cost of the two trackers. Third-party reviewers keep describing it as lightweight monitoring with alerts, which fits.
What none of the three do
I could not find independent testing of data accuracy, or of how each tool collects responses (real interface scraping versus API calls). That matters because user-facing answers and citations can differ from API output. Ask each vendor directly before you commit, and check what trial terms apply, since I could not verify any.
None of these three, going by their pricing pages, covers AI crawler logs or AI-referred visitor analytics. So you can see whether you are cited, but not whether AI bots actually read your pages or whether the citations send any traffic. For a small team that is the gap that bites in month three, when someone asks what the tracking has produced.
This is where a platform that closes the loop is worth a look. Promptwatch tracks the same AI engines but also adds IP-verified crawler logs, visitor analytics, and a Content Agent that writes and publishes pages against your visibility gaps. Its Essential plan is $95 a month, the same as Peec Starter, and every plan includes unlimited seats, Brand Narrative and visitor analytics. Content generation starts on higher tiers, so check promptwatch.com/pricing for what each plan includes.

Decision guide
| If you are... | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Testing whether AI visibility matters, budget under $50 | Otterly Lite | $29, quick setup |
| A team of 4+ who all need dashboards | Peec Starter or Pro | Unlimited users |
| Tracking 150+ prompts on a tight budget | Otterly Standard | $1.18 per prompt |
| Short on writing capacity, $600 available | Gauge Growth | 18 articles and CMS publishing |
| Wanting tracking, crawler data and content under one roof | Promptwatch | Closed loop from monitoring to published pages |
A practical way to run the trial
- Write 15 to 20 prompts your buyers actually use, a mix of branded, comparison and category questions.
- Pick the same three engines across tools where you can, so results are comparable.
- Run for two weeks before judging. Single-day snapshots swing a lot.
- Count how many recommendations you actually shipped. That number, not the dashboard, tells you whether the tool earns its fee.
- Check your own server or analytics for AI referrals so you can tie visibility to visits.
If you want to widen the shortlist, the directories at bestgeosoftware.com and ai-rank-tools.com list dozens of other trackers, including budget options like [tool:brandaxis] and [tool:geoptie] for small teams.
Verdict
For a genuinely lightweight start, Otterly.AI wins on price and Peec AI wins on seats and breadth of included features. Gauge wins only if you want content bundled and can justify $599. If you are a small team, the better question is not which tracker, but what happens after the tracking, and whether you want to pay for a dashboard or for results. Confirm all prices on the vendors' pages before buying, because every one of these has changed in recent months.
If you are weighing whether to hire help with the optimization side instead of buying more software, 1001 SEO Media runs GEO programs for teams that would rather not do it themselves.

