Key takeaways
- Cheapest cost per answer on paper is Airefs (about $9.80 per 1,000 answers), but it covers four engines, is agency-focused, and its self-serve availability is unclear.
- Peec AI ($95/mo) and Rankscale Pro ($99/mo) land close together at roughly $20 to $21 per 1,000 answers. Peec is simpler. Rankscale covers more engines but burns credits faster on API models.
- Otterly.AI has the lowest sticker price at $29/mo, but Lite is thin: 20 prompts and 3 of 7 engines.
- A lot of third-party roundups are stale. Rankscale's $17-20 Essentials plan is no longer on its pricing page, and Otterly's prompt counts have changed. Check live pricing pages before you buy.
- None of these four tell you much about what to do on Monday. If you need optimization and content execution, budget for something beyond a tracker.
Why budget trackers are hard to compare
I went into this expecting a simple price table. It isn't. Each of these four vendors counts usage in a different unit, so "50 prompts" at one tool and "120 credits" at another tell you nothing without some arithmetic.
- Peec AI counts prompts across models and days, and gives you a monthly answer allowance.
- Otterly.AI counts prompts against credits.
- Rankscale sells credits. Prompts are unlimited, but each run spends credits.
- Airefs counts answers directly.
So the only fair way to compare them is cost per 1,000 AI answers. I'll do that below, then go through where each tool pinches.
One warning before the details. Several roundups published in 2026 still list old numbers. Otterly's prompt counts shifted, and the cheap Rankscale Essentials tier that shows up in many lists is gone from the official page. Where sources conflict, I use the vendor pricing pages and tell you so. Prices also moved around Black Friday, so confirm on the live page.

The four tools at a glance
| Tool | Entry plan | Mid plan | Engines | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peec AI | $95/mo, 50 prompts, 4,500 answers | $245/mo, 150 prompts, 13,500 answers | Pick 3 at a time below Enterprise | Teams that want clean daily tracking and unlimited seats |
| Otterly.AI | $29/mo, 20 prompts | $189/mo, 160 prompts | 3 of 7 engines below Enterprise | Small budgets testing the category |
| Rankscale | Pro $99/mo ($84.15 billed yearly) | Pro+ $229/mo | 17+ engines on every plan | Wide engine coverage and international tracking |
| Airefs | $49/mo billed yearly ($59 monthly), 5,000 answers | Extra answers $8 per 1,000 | ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Gemini, Copilot | Agencies with many small clients |
Peec AI
Peec is the one I'd point most SEO teams at first. Starter is $95/mo for 50 prompts, 4,500 answers a month, one project, one country, daily tracking and unlimited users. Pro is $245/mo (150 prompts, 2 projects, 3 countries, 13,500 answers) and Advanced is $495/mo (350 prompts, 5 projects, Looker Studio, 31,500 answers).
What I like: every plan has unlimited competitors, unlimited languages, citation share, source classification, gap analysis, a fanout overview, AI Shopping tracking and a crawlability audit. That's a lot of analysis for the price. Swydo's agency roundup also names Peec the best all-round pick for most agencies.
What bugs me: you choose only 3 engines at a time below Enterprise, from ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini, Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE and Bing AI Mode. Multi-country is an Advanced feature. And some brand perception features (custom attributes, objections cadence) are gated by plan.
Otterly.AI

Otterly has the lowest barrier to entry. Lite is $29/mo with 20 prompts (2,000 credits), 3 of 7 engines, daily tracking and three recommendations a week. Standard is $189/mo for 160 prompts, and Premium is $489/mo for 535 prompts. Annual billing is 15% off.
Engines on the list are ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot, AI Mode, Gemini and Claude, but every paid plan below Enterprise gets only 3. Citation tracking, brand profiling, sentiment and ChatGPT Ads tracking are on Lite. API and MCP access, agent analytics and the Data Studio connector start at Standard.
A flag on the data: Otterly's pricing page is internally inconsistent. The page body says 20 / 160 / 535 prompts, while the metadata still says 15 / 100 / 400, and third-party reviews repeat the older numbers. Verify on the live page. Also, extra credits are pricey: 5,000 credits cost $65/mo on Standard.
Otterly is a good place to learn what AI tracking looks like. It is lighter on optimization guidance than higher-priced platforms, which several reviewers note.
Rankscale

Rankscale is the odd one out. Prompts are unlimited, but every run costs credits, and the cost depends on the engine. GUI-scraped engines (ChatGPT, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Gemini, Bing AI Mode) are 0.25 credits per run, so four answers per credit. API calls cost 1 to 4 credits, and web-search variants cost 3 to 4. If you run lots of API models, that math falls apart fast.
Current plans from the official page: Pro $99/mo ($84.15 yearly) with up to 4,800 answers, 10 brand dashboards and 50 page audits; Pro+ $229/mo with 12,000 answers and a REST API; Growth $385/mo with 22,000 answers and white-label links; Enterprise $780/mo. All plans cover 17+ engines, all countries and all languages. Extra brand dashboards are $9/mo each.
The $17 to $20 Essentials plan quoted in many 2026 listicles does not appear on the current pricing page. If a blog tells you Rankscale starts at $17, treat that as out of date until you see it on rankscale.ai/pricing. A 50% off first two months Black Friday code (RANKNOV26) ran through Nov 30.
It's rated 4.6/5 on OMR Reviews. Peec vs Rankscale write-ups tend to land on the same split: Peec wins on transparent pricing and team features, Rankscale on engine breadth and international coverage.
Airefs
Airefs is built for agencies. One plan: $49/mo billed yearly ($59 monthly), with unlimited clients, prospects, prompts and reports, and 5,000 AI answers a month. Extra answers are $8 per 1,000. Engines are ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Gemini and Copilot, chosen per client, with Claude as a paid add-on. Perplexity and AI Mode are not listed.
It refreshes daily, every 3 days or every 7 days, supports unlimited countries, white-label PDF reports, an MCP server, and tracks AI crawler visits and AI-referred visits. That last part is unusual at this price.
Caveats, and they matter. The "get early access" flow goes through a booked call, so I can't tell whether you can just sign up and start. Its 4.9/5 G2 rating comes from 13 reviews, all five stars, which is a small sample. And I found no independent Airefs vs Peec comparison, so the cost claims below come from the vendor itself.
Cost per 1,000 answers
Here is the normalized math, using entry plans on GUI-style tracking. This is my arithmetic from the published figures.
| Tool | Plan | Monthly price | Answers | Approx. cost per 1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Airefs | Single plan (yearly billing) | $49 | 5,000 | $9.80 |
| Rankscale | Pro (GUI engines) | $99 | 4,800 | $20.60 |
| Peec AI | Starter | $95 | 4,500 | $21 |
| Otterly.AI | Lite | $29 | 2,000 credits (20 prompts) | Not directly comparable |
Airefs's own comparison table claims $0.0098 per answer for itself versus $0.0205 for Peec and $0.0443 for Profound. Those are vendor claims, but my numbers agree with the Peec figure. I left Otterly out of the answer math because its credit-to-answer conversion depends on how many engines and how often you run prompts. At $29 it's cheap to start, but at Standard ($189 for 160 prompts) it is no bargain.
Where each one pinches
- Engine limits: Peec and Otterly cap you at 3 active engines on mid-tier plans. Rankscale is all engines but consumes credits faster on API models. Airefs gives four engines plus a Claude add-on.
- Feature gating: Otterly gates API and MCP to Standard. Peec gates multi-country to Advanced. Rankscale gates the REST API to Pro+.
- Seats: Peec and Otterly both include unlimited users. Airefs includes unlimited clients.
- Stale reviews: most online price lists predate the current plans. Treat any blog post older than a few weeks with suspicion.

Why prompt design matters more than you'd think
Trackers run your prompts, but AI engines also run their own hidden searches. Promptwatch's ChatGPT query fanout data shows average fanouts per response falling from 2.15 in early December 2025 to about 1.84 by early March 2026, then reading 1.0 per response from April after a gap in the data. Average fanout query length dropped from about 117 characters to roughly 53 from April. (The report page also says "3-8+ searches per prompt", which conflicts with those measured averages, so I'm going with the averages.)
The practical takeaway: shorter, keyword-style queries mean your tracked prompts should be written the way real people actually ask, and fanout visibility is worth having. Peec lists a fanout overview, and reviews of Rankscale mention fan-out tracking too.
Which one should you buy
| If you are... | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A solo founder or small team who wants to try tracking | Otterly.AI Lite | $29/mo, easiest entry, but expect to outgrow 20 prompts |
| An SEO team that wants daily tracking with solid analysis | Peec AI Starter | Clean UI, unlimited users, source analysis on every plan |
| A team tracking many engines or many countries | Rankscale Pro | 17+ engines, all countries, but watch credit burn on API models |
| An agency with many small clients | Airefs | Unlimited clients and white-label reports, if you can get access |
My opinion: Peec is the safest default, Rankscale is the right choice only if engine breadth is the point, Otterly is a learning tool, and Airefs is the most interesting number on paper that I'd verify with a trial before committing.
When a budget tracker is not enough
These four report. They don't do much about what they find. A visibility score that says you appear in 34% of answers doesn't tell you which page to write on Monday. If you want tracking plus the fixing, with IP-verified AI crawler logs, a content gap analysis, a Content Agent that publishes to your CMS, and traffic attribution, look at Promptwatch. Essential starts at $95/mo, and there is a 7-day free trial on monthly billing; confirm current prices at promptwatch.com/pricing.

It is a bigger commitment than a $29 tracker, and you won't need it on day one. But if tracking is working and nothing is changing, that's the signal. You can also run the free AI visibility report first to see how ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity describe your brand. For side-by-side feature coverage, see Promptwatch vs Peec and Promptwatch vs Otterly.
If you want more options, the AI rank tracking directory at ai-rank-tools.com lists dozens of alternatives.
Final checklist before you pay
- Open each vendor's live pricing page. Don't trust a roundup, including this one, for final numbers.
- Convert everything to cost per 1,000 answers for the engines you actually need.
- Count your engines. If you need more than 3, Peec and Otterly will force an upgrade to Enterprise.
- Ask what is gated: API, MCP, multi-country, agent analytics.
- Run a 2-week trial with the same 30 prompts on two tools and compare what each one tells you to do next.
The cheapest tracker isn't the one with the lowest price tag. It's the one whose credits, engines and prompts match how you'll really use it.

